Thursday, February 4, 2010

In chapter seventeen, Dimmesdale and Hester finally meet. They tell each other about how their lives have been in the past seven years, and conclude that Chillingworth is the worst of the three sinners. An at first reluctant Dimmesdale finally agrees to run away from the town with Hester. When Hester proposed this plan, I started wondering why she stayed in the town all those years in the first place. She could have escaped long ago and lived a better life. After taking the scarlet letter off her bosom and throwing it to the ground, Hester pins it back on her dress in the end. I think that maybe Hester wants to be with Dimmesdale, but doesn't want to discard the scarlet letter because it represents Pearl. I think it is a good idea for Dimmesdale, Hester and Pearl to escape this town for a better life. However, before doing so, I think Dimmesdale should confess to the townspeople. Unfortunately, the biggest obstacle to their plan is Chillingworth. He previously told Hester that he will always be wherever she goes.

1 comment:

  1. Pearl demands that her mother put the letter back on her chest. Do you remember that part of the conversation? At one point, Hester is considering whether to stay; according to the author, she is not quite sure why she stays, but she decides to tell herself that it is where she sinned and should be the site of her retribution. Hawthorne says that she refuses to accept that idea that it might be because of Dimmesdale. Nicely written entry -- is working with a partner helping you to be able to write?

    ReplyDelete